Showing posts with label football. Show all posts
Showing posts with label football. Show all posts

Sunday, September 24, 2017

Boycott Football!!!

I used to watch football (on television). I was never a passionate fan, by any stretch, but I followed it and could at least pretend to know enough stuff that if the conversation veered in that direction I wouldn’t say something so ridiculous that it would reveal the depth of my ignorance.
No more. And it has nothing to do with the fake issue of the national anthem (an event that wasn’t even shown on televised broadcasts unless it featured a famous singer), or a draft-dodging president ginning up outrage over a lack of patriotism. I gave it up even before Stan Kroenke jilted St. Louis and took the Rams back to Los Angeles. I started to see it as a thuggish, brutish “sport” that glorified violence and then feigned surprise when its actors carried that same violence off the field. (See: Hey! Are You Ready For Some Fuhball! Unnhhh! Me, not so much.)
I have even better reasons, now, to be thankful that I didn’t have a son to convince not to play the game. because nothing demonstrates cognitive dissonance better than football. A large majority of Americans (83% according to one poll) believe that football is dangerous to the participants, that it “certainly” or “probably” causes brain injuries. Would that number be even higher if more people knew about the study showing 110 of 111 former professional football players’ autopsies showed CTE? Three out of four people say that head injuries are a major problem for the sport.
Three out of four also identify as fans of football and almost half say it’s their favorite sport to watch. Parents encourage their sons to play, from a young age, a sport that risks their long-term health, both physical and mental, that encourages a culture of violence. A study out of Virginia and North Carolina showed that 19 boys, aged 7 & 8, had taken over 3000 hits to the head in practice and games. Players aged 9-12 had averaged 240 hits to the head per player, with more force than people might expect. Over 25,000 football players aged 8 to 19 are treated in emergency rooms for concussions each year. (The Week, Vol. XIII, #639, p. 20)
About 90% of retired NFL players are in pain daily. Almost half (44%) have either had or been recommended to have joint replacement surgery. The goal of football is for (almost universally large) players to run into each other, knock each down or out of the way, play after play, and day after day if you include practice. Pretty sure the human body is neither intended nor built to take that kind of abuse. Despite President Trump’s bemoaning how football is being softened and made less “manly” (my words, his implication), the risks of this sport make whatever pleasure might be available as a spectator clearly not worth it (to me).
While I admit that the vast majority of retired football players claim they are happy they played, despite their projected shortened and painful life spans, I would suggest that the decision is not quite as completely personal as you might expect. The costs to the medical system for the health care of these men is not borne solely by them, but by society at large. Their costs, like the costs for those who decline to wear helmets when riding motorcycles (or even bicycles, for that matter) are not limited to them.
So if you’re boycotting football, I’m happy to join you (even if no one notices — I haven’t watched a game in years), because anything that diminishes the football culture in this country is okay by me. Just understand, I have my own reasons, and patriotic outrage isn’t one of them.

Just for fun, from the University of Snapple, early football fields had both horizontal AND vertical stripes, making it resemble, wait for it, a gridiron.

Saturday, October 19, 2013

Hey! Are You Ready For Some Fuhball! Unnhhh! Me, not so much.





10. All but 1 of 111 NFL players' brains examined had CTE
A study published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that all but one of the 111 brains of deceased NFL players examined showed signs of the neurodegenerative brain disease chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). The brains were donated for scientific research, mostly by relatives who suspected the late players had exhibited symptoms of CTE — which can only be diagnosed with an autopsy — including memory loss, confusion, and depression. The players whose brains were examined spanned every position, from quarterbacks to running backs to linemen. Neuropathologist Ann McKee cautioned against making generalizations about the incidence of CTE in larger populations, but said the study made one thing clear: "It is no longer debatable whether or not there is a problem in football — there is a problem."
Source: JAMA, The New York Times
Having (possibly) offended the 5-10% who have been or are cheerleaders, let’s go for the 50+% who are fans of football (percentages may be higher in locales where the sport is also the state religion, like Texas and Ohio, for example).

The NFL is asking for stories about “Why do you love football?” I’m pretty sure what follows won’t win me those tickets to the Super Bowl. I’m also sure I don’t care, unless they show the commercials on the stadium screen. I could sell my tickets, of course, but if you continue to read this, it’s obviously a moot point.

I used to watch football, a little, but was never a huge fan. Maybe that was a combined result of going to a high school without a football team, or to a small college where hockey was the primary sport (we did have football), followed by an urban university with no team, and a career at a high school without a team. My allegiance, tepid as it is, to football teams is more about city or state loyalty than caring about the sport.
Maybe that’s why, but I don’t think so. I know my view is a minority one, but, to me, football is a thuggish, brutish sport that glorifies violence and hurting your opponent. That’s not all it is, of course, but that’s my take on its bottom line. I’ve been conducting a completely unscientific survey. It has one question: “Would/Will you let your son play football?” Most answers to this point are immediate and negative.
A study out of Virginia and North Carolina showed that 19 boys, aged 7 & 8, had taken over 3000 hits to the head in practice and games. Players aged 9-12 had averaged 240 hits to the head per player, with more force than people might expect. Over 25,000 football players aged 8 to 19 are treated in emergency rooms for concussions each year.1 A basic knowledge of anatomy makes the risks manifest. Helmets, no matter how well designed, cannot do the job of protecting kids’ brains, to say nothing of neck whiplashes from these blows; helmets do even less for that. 
The evidence seems clear to me that the physical dangers of the game to the players clearly outweigh any possible entertainment value. Multiple concussions leading to long-term mental health problems, arthritis resulting from joint damage, frequent surgeries, sprains and broken bones, and for what? So that half-naked drunks in body paint can scream out their own aggressions and frustrations? So that frustrated fathers can live vicariously through their children? My kid’s tougher than yours, so that makes me better. When was the last time you watched a football game (at any level) without an injury of some kind, without some player limping, wobbling, staggering, or (even worse) being carried from the field? I clearly don’t get it.
I’m less clear about the mental aspects, where I will concede the valuable lessons of teamwork, sportsmanship, sacrifice, etc. but still question the testosterone-poisoned atmosphere. As noted above, however, I’m an outsider and freely admit that there’s perhaps more benefit than I can possibly know. I would suggest, however, that those admittedly worthwhile lessons could be learned in a less violent venue. Do we really want our sons, nephews, grandsons, etc. growing up to be the stereotypical football player? Are we really willing to risk the physical, and at least occasionally long-lasting or even permanent, damage to our children? 
I concede that there are counterpoints that make this a tougher question than I’ve painted it. I’m just glad I have a daughter and granddaughter. Life is risky enough without throwing children into the middle of a violent scrum.

1 The Week, Vol. XIII, #639, p. 20